Frantz Fanon is one of the well-known decolonial scholars. He has developed the concept of the zone of nonbeing which discusses the positionality of the colonised and oppressed and oppressed people in general and black people in particular. The notion of the zone of nonbeing has resurfaced in decolonial discourses in Southern Africa including Namibia.
INTRODUCTION
The
notion of zone of nonbeing has been shown in the decolonial discourses in
Southern Africa notable and Namibia included where we see scholars and
Pan-Africanist using both diplomacy and violence to gain independence from
former colonial masters and to make possible the end of zones. These zones
comprise of zone of being and zone of nonbeing, in the zone of being are white
people considered to be human and in the zone of nonbeing are black people
considered to be inhuman, objects in fact. Notwithstanding that this
classification of people into zones does not only include the race issue, it
goes to the depths of social status, tribal differences or even just not being
from the same family which can be said in simpler terms as nepotism. The zone
of none being has been depicted in Namibia in both pre and post-independence
eras. The following essay will further elaborate on this issue bringing out evidence
to pivot the ideas that will be raised where there is a depiction of the zone
of nonbeing.
THE ZONE OF NONBEING
The zone where the natives live is not complementary to the zone
inhabited by the settlers. The two zones are opposed, but not in the service of
a higher unity. Obedient to the rules of pure Aristotelian logic, they both
follow the principle of reciprocal exclusivity. No conciliation is possible,
for of the two terms, one is superfluous. The settlers' town is a strongly
built town, all made of stone and steel. It is a brightly lit town; the streets
are covered with asphalt, and the garbage cans swallow all the leavings,
unseen, unknown and hardly thought about. Fanon (1963). This is clearly a
description of the reserve system which was introduced by the German colonial
state and perfected by the Union of South Africa rule in the then South West
Africa as Du Pisani (2010) postulate. Black man were removed from the old
location to infertile, dry and hot Kalahari and the white settlers got the best
suitable places in the country like at Swakopmund. This culmination of events
explicitly show that the zone of nonbeing is a reality that led to the
dismemberment of the black man from his humanity, his land, his property, his
feelings.
THE ZONE OF NONBEING IN NAMIBIA-CASE 1
This case with look at what took place in
Pre-colonial Namibia in general exhibiting the notion of zone of nonbeing and
how it affected those who were dehumanized. What happened at the Shark Island
was symbolic of a zone of nonbeing during 1904 to 1907. There was a
concentration camp set up by the German Colonial State and this led to the
massacre of more than 100 000 Hereros and Namas, in what was termed the
genocide of the 20th century, some were beheaded and their heads
taken to museums in German and some where used for experiments to really see if
the black man was a human of which the whites then did not accept such a
reality that both black and white man are at par, socially, economically and
politically. The Germans did this to advance their theories of racial supremacy
(Williams, 2010). So by seeing the black man as racially inferior just because
of his skin colour shows dehumanization at its climax, the genocide itself
imbeds the ideas of black man as an object that is meant to suffer. It has been
said the Negro is the link between
monkey and the man- of course the white man (Fanon, 1952) stresses Fanon this
is a clear depiction of the black man as equally to an animal as he is put
below the level of the white man, he is called a link between an animal and a
man, then what is a black man?. The zone of nonbeing has alienated the black
man from his society at large. And to this end it can be concluded that the
notion of the zone of nonbeing is applicable to Namibia.
During the Apartheid state, the notion of
the zone of nonbeing comes to picture. This state fractured the ranks of the
ruled along a double divide; ethnic on the other hand, rural/urban on the
other. (Du Pisani, 2010). This culminated in restrictions of mobility and
ethnic zoning of rural and urban space to create distance between tribes and to
weaken uprisings. This shows that the Apartheid was fractured and hegemonic as
it divided the society along ethnic lines to ensure White minority hegemony. Introduction
of the Vagrancy Proclamation Act of 1920 which was complemented by the Native
Passes Proclamation 1930 (Labour Resource and Research Institute, 2009) was a
clear indication of putting the black man into zones physically and it had
psychological effects of alienation and being subjected into the poor, arid
Kalahari Desert. Thus from this analysis it can be noted that therefore the
applicability of the notion of the zone of nonbeing is overwhelming in Namibia
as it started in the colonial Namibia in both phases of colonisation, German
colonisation at first and Apartheid State at the end.
THE ZONE OF NONBEING IN NAMIBIA-CASE 2
Coming into the Independent Namibia, we
have a lot of cases that exhibit the notion of zone of nonbeing and its
applicability. Under this chapter will look at the cultural practices that have
been taking place here in Namibia that have an effect on dehumanization of a
particular group of people. This has been notable in Zambezi Region through
harmful cultural practices that affect the girl child. The first practice is
locally known as sikenge in the
Zambezi region were a girl is cut on her back with an unsterilized razor blade
and with no pain killers. This process is also called kupaza , it is a form of scarification. Some girls undertook this
process freely some do not have a choice, and the process last a month which
affects girl’s education and mostly leads to dropping out. These harmful
cultural practices were not reserved for a girl’s menarche alone; the trauma
and violation follow them in all stages of their lives.(Titus, 2017, P. 6) Showing a zone of nonbeing as a girl is being
a sacrificial lamb of barbaric cultural practises that bring more harm than
good in their lives, it shows how girls are being disadvantaged while their
counterparts are progressing, the boys, so here it is quite clear that the
zones are gender based and girls seem to fall on the disadvantageous side. From
this analysis it is crystal clear that the notion of the zone of nonbeing is
applicable to Namibia.
In Post-Independent Namibia it has been
noted that there is a notion when it comes to occupying public offices.
Preference is not on merit rather it is on if someone has been to exile during
the colonial era, and being a comrade. This issue has connotations of the
notion of the zone of nonbeing as it is classifying people in an unfair manner.
This has been noted with the struggle kids (kids of those who went to exile)
given first preferences when it comes to vacant posts in the government. The
question is also what is left for other, perhaps even more qualified, young job
seekers when preference is given to the 'struggle kids'? And what will this
mean for the promise of increased productivity in the public service, when the
'struggle kids', on their own admission, have only basic education? (Lister, 2009,
p.1) asks the Namibian reporter, this is an indication of grouping people into
zones, and a zone of nonbeing comprise of the youths who were born in their
motherland Namibia which they did not choose to. This notion of preferring
struggle kids over qualified Namibian youth have had a backlash in what
President Hage Geingob calls bloated government (Kahiurika, 2017, p.3). Thus to
this end the zone of nonbeing is causing national problems as it leads to
maladministration on the government’s part.
THE ZONE OF NONBEING IN NAMIBIA-CASE 3
The land issue has been one of the factors
where undertones of the notion of the zone of nonbeing have been envisaged in
Namibia. This has been largely caused by the slower process of the willing
buyer willing seller criteria the government adapted which has led to creation
of informal settlements around main towns in Namibia particularly Windhoek.
This was noted with the recent actions by the city of Windhoek police department
repeating what happened during the Apartheid era, when the colonial Windhoek
municipality forcefully removed and killed black residents from the Old
Location in order to pave way for the whites only plush suburbs Hochland Park
and Pioneers Park. Now the current City of Windhoek has done it again at 7de
Laan informal settlement in Otjomuise (Kamwanyah, 2017, p.10). On this notion
it can be noted that what only have changed is the skin colour of the enforcers
and this critically brings how changing the issue of zone of nonbeing from
racial matters to an issue between one black man and his fellow, this brings
the idea which Fanon expounds in his works which he called colonial hauntology
(A. Du Pisani, personal communication, April 26, 2017), there is alienation of
a black man by another black man which shows the effects of colonisation on the
black man. This is quite ironical because this state institution must protect
the citizens as the Namibian constitution alludes and they left Namibian citizens
to sleep in open cold which shows they even dehumanised these families to
animals which shows the applicability of the notion of the zone of nonbeing in
Namibia.
Under economical cases where the notion of
the zone of nonbeing is brought out is the case of Security Guards in Namibia,
they have been the topic of thought among people in social spheres dehumanizing
them just because of their occupation and the society’s hollow belief that they
are uneducated. Security guards have faced a lot of problems in their field of
speciality, from lack of respect from their employees to lack of respect from
people they protect. These security guards are taken for granted by their
companies who are making billions around the world only to pay them peanuts,
this prompted one of the guards here in Namibia plying her trade in Rundu she
said that “being a security guard is not good, the money for work is too
little, we are not even able to pay for bread.” (Titus, 2017, p.3). This is an
indication of putting people into zones just because of their social and
economic status and the output they bring contributes to tranquillity in the
society. It is in this sense that we see the mistreatment of guards by the
companies that employ them by not providing them warm clothing during night
shifts. Thus from this analysis it can be noted that the notion of zone of none
being is applicable in Namibia as this practice is similar to that of Apartheid
state where people were put into reserves to provide cheap labour for white
owned mines and factories.
THE ZONE OF NONBEING IN NAMIBIA-CASE 4
This last case will look at social cases
notably those that the state is depriving people of their rights. Prostitution
is one of the main examples In
normative terms, Namibian society throughout the variety of its traditional and
Christian cultures – regards prostitution as socially and legally un acceptable
and undesirable. Accordingly, public perception sometimes even tends to deny
its existence (Horner 2006:2). However, scientific examination allows only one
inference: prostitution is deeply institutionalised in Namibian society. The
current research found prostitution in Windhoek a clearly visible, 24-hour
activity (Kiremire, 2007). Nonetheless it remains a crime to practise
prostitution in Namibia which is ironical in the sense that the Namibian
constitution is hailed as one of the transparent constitution’s on the African
continent to date as the bill of rights is entrenched therein. There is need to
grant prostitutes their dignity for they suffer society stigmatization as they
are often poked as immoral while their customers do not carry such a label on
their back which brings us to a conclusion that there is a zone of nonbeing in
this issue as women are on pointed to in this chauvinistic and patriarchal
society that hide behind the veil of ignorance.
CONCLUSION
The zone of nonbeing continue to haunt modern day
South African States particularly Namibia is a remnant of the colonial forces
that affected the black man to an extend of following actions of his colonial
master on his neighbour as depicted on the City of Windhoek saga, issues to do
with individual rights and a lot more discussed in the above well-articulated
assessment. The assessment went on to the roots of the causes of the zone of
nonbeing in post-colonial discourse in Southern Africa when it all started with
events that took place at the Shark Island concentration camps where Hereros
and Namas were beheaded for experiments in German and for tourism purposes in
Museums and Galleries which shows how
close to an animal Europeans thought Africans where just because of the fact
they were afriaid to admit to the reality that there was a better being than
them. This led them to come up with a colonial education that aimed at
advancing their superiority on Africans which is a clear indication of fear on
the Europeans part. Thus they came up with two zones, the zone of being which
they belonged to and a zone of nonbeing they placed the African man.
References
1.
Du Pisani, A (2010). State and Society under
South African rule. In Keulder, C (ed) State, Society and Democracy: A
Reader in Namibian Politics. Windhoek: Konrad Adenauer Stiftung.
2.
Fanon, F (1963). The Wretched of the Earth. New
York: Groove Press
3. Horner,
Hayden. 2006. “Namibia: Govt and NGO launch joint assault against HIV/AIDS”. Integrated
Regional Information Networks PlusNews. www.plusnews.org/AIDSreport.asp?ReportID=6379&SelectRegion=Southern_Africa11/18/2006;
last accessed 06 May 2017.
4.
Kahiurika, N. (2017, February 28). Reconciliation to
blame for bloated Govt- Geingob. The
Namibian, p. 3
5.
Kamwanyah, N. (2017, April 7).Windhoek City Needs a
Heart Too. The Namibian, p. 10
6. Kiremire
, M. (2007, p.13) Prostitution in Windhoek, Namibia: An Exploration of Poverty.
Institute of Democracy. Volume 4 (2007)2
7.
Lister, G. (2009,
November 13) Political Perspectives. The
Namibian, p. 1
8.
Titus, H. (2017, February 22). Suffering in the name of
culture. The Namibian, p. 6
9.
Titus, H. (2017, March 7). The Tough Life of a Security
Guard. The Namibian, p. 3
10. Williams,
M. (2010, September 23). Hitler's Holocaust
blueprint: A new book reveals how the Kaiser's Germany used concentration camps
in Africa to advance their theories of racial supremacy. Mail online, (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1314399/Hitlers-Holocaust-blueprint-Africa-concentration-camps-used-advance-racial-theories.html#ixzz4gHAyMNp8) last accessed 6 May 2017
Comments
Post a Comment